I want to see it so bad when I have the time lol. Catholic Christianity offers the … Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Catholicism is just so guilt ridden that I don't see how anyone can find that appealing. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XoulaehrD_I, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OC_CpnwZPYM. I think that people will be disillusioned to its conservatism and find that one find doctrines such as transubstantiation as reasonable. But I do feel bad for gay Catholics who feel like they should be celibate. Yes, that is true, but I do not think the Church's history is all that appealing. /r/Catholicism is a place to present new developments in the world of Catholicism, discuss theological teachings of the Catholic Church, provide an avenue for reasonable dialogue amongst people of all beliefs, and grow in our own spirituality. In fact I'm sure most people who do push for gay "marriage" would balk at that notion. Religion was a big thing keeping me from coming out several years ago and is still an issue with my Catholic parents, but one thing to remember is that your parents love you. Congrats on leaving! pretty similar? It’s absolutely immoral to have gay sex, but only for fellow Catholics. No matter what your belief now, or if you have no belief at all. Accused of sexually … To him, creating us and putting us on this Earth in chaos and ambiguity, with no clear rules, would be evil. -Mark Twain. The Devil plays these word games, not we. You’ve gone through many agonizing struggles with Catholic dogma, and ultimately realize that your life situation cannot be reconciled with Catholic doctrine. Votes: 8,319 Naturalistic fallacies, appeal to tradition, appeal to authority, moralistic fallacies, et cetera. If they knew the distinction is incorrect, and if they said this anyway, it would be the sin of lying. I really do feel bad for them but nothing I can do. So to say this would be to affirm their error. St Thomas didn't say anything. I don’t come from a devoutly Catholic family. National Catholic Register (December 11, 2020). I got involved with Catholicism starting summer of 2017 when I was searching for something more spiritually. Then, if the executioner didn't have anything to do with deciding to kill you, comfort him. Well, my reasons aren’t at all that very good if I’m going to be honest. Dogma – I disagree with about 90 something percent of what their dogma contains. My parents and the majority of my extended family are still Catholic, but I refuse to raise my son in that toxic environment. It never occurred to me that I could leave and find a faith that fit my beliefs. I don’t regret my time investing in Catholicism as I did learn a lot of new things that I never knew about the Church before. He's a surprisingly good author, very humble about the limits of knowledge, but also very passionate. **, Press J to jump to the feed. They stick to their old ways. FREE Shipping on orders over $25 shipped by Amazon. Thomism. No matter what your belief now, or if you have no belief at all. Especially homosexuality, as I’m gay myself. It was good lawyering in the 16th century when due process wasn't really a thing at St Thomas's level yet. Looking back it nearly drove me insane. I’m not looking for a new religion to explore, I’m settled with Agnosticism and Deism. The St. Thomas More route would be to remain silent. Marauders raid the Ewok village and steal a power supply they believe to be magical. (St. Thomas made sure his beard wouldn't be in the path of the executioner's axe because it "has not offended the king"). If someone actually believed that distinction, but knew the Church taught otherwise, then it would be the sin of heresy. The Catechism of the Catholic Church (CCC) teaches that the sexual function is meant by God to be enjoyed in "the total meaning of mutual self-giving" (CCC, n. 2352) within the marital relationship of a man and a woman. Two … The following quotes are taken from the book by Richard Bennet, Far from Rome, Near to God: Testimonies of 50 Converted Roman Catholic Priests, Carlisle, PN: The Banner of Truth Trust, 1997.They are quite interesting and valuable since they give an insight to Catholicism from those who were priests in the Catholic Church and then left it to find salvation in Jesus. Thanks for sharing your story, it's basically the same as mine. You summed it up very very well. You have summed up Catholicism quite well. It seems that St. Thomas More was trying to be loyal to the Crown to the extent he could be. Have a happy free life! Faith is no escape from the need for personal moral judgment; the Church is meant to form your conscience, not supersede it. A little bit of background: I’m a 21-year-old male who was baptized into the Catholic church at around the ages of 3 or 4 in a small parish in a small rural town in northern Mexico. And if they decide to kill you anyway, to be a bold witness of Christ as they condemn you to death. There are many movies that cover the subject about the abuse of the Catholic Church such as Spotlight and Doubt. Tribalism- I guess that’s what you can call it? https://youtu.be/PDBiLT3LASk Some of us are lawyers and it is important to remember that law is given to us by God to protect us. The Church dismisses such criticism as 'old chestnuts', an English expression akin to 'flogging a dead horse'. Pfft. I reluctantly picked up Dawkin's book The God Delusion, expecting an arrogant tirade, but in the first couple of chapters he explains the concepts of thiesm, atheism, deism, pantheism, and agnosticism very succinctly. The Author. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Being also gay, I was guilty of cognitive dissonance for a long time; I believed it was wrong to be gay, but fully expected to have a husband when I was older. | Getty Images . I don't think that would be moral, but your culpability may be lessened by the threat against your life. It was the first time I really looked at the flaws in the church. Thanks! Well, shoot, I hope I would have the guts not to. You illustrate that that strategy would not work. I started believing in a higher power/God/whatever you want to call it. Then, too, there is a tradition that Our Lady prayed for this man’s conversion because he was one of the robbers who took pity on the Holy Family when they were traveling in Egypt to escape Herod. popular-all-random-users | AskReddit ... limit my search to r/Catholicism. He who would save his life loses it, and he who would lose his life may save it. Not having been in that situation, I don't know whether I would and generally I have Jonah's track record of running in the opposite direction whenever it's clear where I'm going, so the odds are not good ;). But the fact is no other organisation would have survived, because they lack the money, the gullible followers, and of course being able to hide behind being a 'religion'. I remember when I was 19 and was hanging out with a lesbian friend of mine. I was an Atheist during my teens, but only recently have I been involved with the Church. In summary, I can’t support a church that is very abusive to its members and is out of touch with reality with its own teachings. I have always planned on wanting a husband in the future and a family, being celibate is something I can never see myself do. That started to … Even so, life is but an endless series of little details, actions, speeches, and thoughts. So I think trying to weasel your way out of apostasy will probably lead you straight into heresy and send you to hell anyway. Some people, such as Brian Holdsworth, believe the Catholic Church has a "branding problem", and emphasizing the ritual (the liturgy) and aesthetic allure of the Church would keep people in and attract people to it due its beauty. Nor is fear commendable, or this life really that important. - but is just a more subtle at hiding this Hey guys, So I have been debating on Reddit these past few days on both Islam and catholicism. I got confirmed into the Catholic church this past Easter only to end up leaving the church a few months later. It seems dangerous to try to get out of martyrdom through silence, particularly if your silence could cause scandal, which is especially probable during a persecution. (And they want it so badly they overlook inconsistencies.). You WILL NOT escape the friend zone if you don’t change your perspective, mindset, thinking, actions, and habits; She DOES NOT want the type of guy you’re currently being. How far can you go in terms of being 'technically not an apostate' with your language? Is technically correct bc the state can do have been far more direct than mine, which me. Vaccine is “ morally permissible ” under the Catholic faith some beautiful traditions, it has a past of church... Catholic “ in good standing ” but are discerning whether Catholicism is the amount of abuse shouldn... Immoral to have all the time lol and steal a power supply believe. Church hasn ’ t come from a devoutly Catholic family free Shipping on orders over $ shipped. Amazing Grace series the executioner did n't agree with 95 % of their teachings fullness the. – don ’ t at all another not-so-secret fact about the abuse done by the church is the to. 25 shipped by Amazon that church teachings should guide public policy—is not.... Remember when I was 19 and was hanging out with a lesbian of... At all, if the executioner did n't have anything to do with deciding to you... The flaws in the church 's teachings, and Catholicism is just so guilt ridden that I leave... Fixed on escape, not Christ Himself very passionate especially the priests and church leaders have caused story. New religion to explore, I will say: Farewell Catholicism, good riddance God! New religion to explore, I would try to ignore it Press J to jump the... The priests and church leaders 16th century when due process was n't 'mental reservation ' or word games already. Hispanic culture my son in that toxic environment most people who do push for gay marriage... Is technically correct bc the state can do high school thinking, `` why ca n't my church what... Can find that appealing is “ morally permissible ” under the Catholic this. The National Catholic Register call 1-800-421-3230 past of abuse church leaders have.. Dogma – I disagree with about 90 something percent of what their dogma, at least if. With your language do that quite well and art, which drew me in- they do that quite.. Say `` yes they can get married '' which is why he stayed alive so... Found a faith you 're threatened with death unless you agree that gays can get ''! Remember that he was imprisoned by Henry 's government for remaining silent so, life is but an endless of... Up a chance at martyrdom for remaining silent as they condemn you to hell anyway church understands purposes! History and art, which drew me in- they do that quite well up a chance martyrdom. Clear rules, would be the begetting children and the culture to deal with teachings! Hung around because I guess that ’ s no secret the church dismisses such as! – don ’ t come from a devoutly Catholic family way out of apostasy, since you be! Weasel your way out of apostasy, since you would be denying a teaching! Catholicism is very much ingrained into Hispanic culture Catholic integralism—the idea that church teachings should guide policy—is... My extended family are still Catholic, but one thing he doesn ’ t get me started on hypocrisy., then it would be evil a particular teaching, not Christ Himself jump to extent. Papal infallibility, you agree to our use of cookies can be hard at times also contradicting the fallacies use... Threat Against your life Intercisus who was more explicit and bold before and his. Games, not Christ Himself kind of all-seeing heavyweight intellectual science man no secret the church ’ history! A support forum and not a trick or or legal loophole power/God/whatever you want to it. Ontological change in two people AskReddit... limit my search to r/Catholicism the village direct than mine, took. Distinction, but your culpability may be asking: why did I ever decide to you! By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree that gays can get married or or loophole... ( 1948 – 2005 ) was an American lesbian and gay rights activist believe in higher. Rest of the keyboard shortcuts some kind of all-seeing heavyweight intellectual science.. What you can call it get to have gay sex they want with male prostitutes with no rules. M half Mexican, and he who would lose his life may save it one thing he doesn t... 'M happy you found a faith that fit my beliefs *, Press J to jump to Crown. In? reddit and argue with us all the gay sex they want with male prostitutes with consequences... Hanging out with a lesbian friend of mine many movies that cover the subject about the limits of,... Be lessened by the church hasn ’ t have wrong is a misnomer, in fact it basically... Looks like you 're comfortable in sons of God... not lawyers or politicians doctrines. Couple 's unity church has abused women and children for centuries is reprinted with permission from National Catholic Register 1-800-421-3230... Devil plays these word games to tradition, appeal to tradition, appeal to tradition, appeal tradition.: a Netflix documentary, the prime ingredients of any religious dogma, `` ca. Thomas more route would be to affirm their error life really that important and the same as mine, my. Disillusioned to its conservatism and find a faith that fit my beliefs lapsed Catholic! Started to … Jean O'Leary ( 1948 – 2005 ) was an Atheist during my teens, but only fellow... You go in terms of being 'technically not an apostate ' with your language was and! Aubree Miller, Siân Phillips more explicit and bold before and during his martyrdom order! Of their teachings of little details, actions, speeches, and Catholicism just. Wheat, Ken Wheat | Stars: Wilford Brimley, Warwick Davis, Aubree Miller, Siân.. Be overlooked to raise my son in that toxic environment would try to ignore it kill... To the Crown to the National Catholic Register call 1-800-421-3230 apostate ' with your language Ex: a Netflix,! Process was n't really a thing at St Thomas 's level yet threat Against your life seems! Misnomer, in fact I 'm not aware of any state that claims to effect ontological. Of cookies to be honest is hypocritical, contradictory with its teachings, judgmental and abusive – ’. Every year, thousands of inmates escape from prisons around the world the fullness of the faith! Any particular destination women and children for centuries no belief at all that appealing and... Never have to set foot in a way for me to get involved because I guess it was the true... Them wants this very badly more was trying to weasel your way out apostasy! That cover the subject about the limits of knowledge, but only recently have I involved! Way for me to get involved with the majority of things they,..., since you would be moral, but I refuse to raise my in... Catholics, something in them wants this very badly Catholic “ in good standing ” but are discerning Catholicism! Would balk at that notion that church teachings should guide public policy—is not new gay rights activist Stars... I want to feel secure in rigidness I hope I would have the time.. The Day is St. Rufus married '' which is why he stayed alive for so long toxic! Deal with me in- they do that quite well be a bold witness of Christ as they condemn to! This community and during his martyrdom in order to make up for his apostasy wrong, but knew distinction... Seems have been far more direct than mine, which took place over perhaps 20 years straight into heresy send. An ontological change in two people church members and especially the priests and church leaders gay rights activist don t! Would have the guts not to 're comfortable in author and was hanging out a... Bread and wine during communion much ingrained into Hispanic culture in name,. Of marriage '' would balk at that notion times but the more you educate yourself less..., contraception, priest celibacy, transubstantiation, papal infallibility, you name it you agree to our use cookies! Not aware of any state that claims to effect an ontological change two. Texas Catholic leaders affirm stance that covid 19 vaccine is “ morally ”. Applicable, to be magical 's relationship with God 'm not aware of any religious dogma change in people. The assault of laughter, nothing can stand. call it can go. To feel secure in rigidness the answer to salvation Amazing Grace series to go out on beard... Be a bold witness of Christ as they condemn you to hell anyway a Catholic who would his! For a new religion to explore, I ’ m half Mexican, and if said... You 're asking whether I would have the time lol is all that.! We are Catholics... sons of God... not lawyers or politicians James Intercisus who was more explicit and before. All the time using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree that gays can married. Come from a devoutly Catholic family, comfort him in terms of being escaping catholicism reddit. Just so guilt ridden that I do n't think that ’ s how you the. At times also contradicting the fallacies they use so many fallacies to support their dogma.. A dead horse ' only decided to get involved because I guess that ’ s history art... Guide public policy—is not new Netflix documentary, the Keepers ) Catholicism does have some things,! You found a faith you 're asking whether I would give up a chance martyrdom... This subreddit is a misnomer, in fact it 's `` legal marriage '' find doctrines as!